They seem all same color makeup.

There are SUBTLE differences. It's easier to see the differences in game. It's hard to take pictures as clear as what in game looks like. The picture of the eyes is as close as I could possibly get before I was inside her head, but the game doesn't take big enough pictures to get a truly accurate representation of what the makeup looks like in game.
Besides, Subtle was asked for, so that's what it is. If you want more dramatic results you can try my other make up.

The colours are, (in no particular order), Silver, Gold, Rose, Blue, Green, and a couple of natural shades.

Love them. Thank You :-)

Looks very natural. Just a question - is it applied directly on a Maxis skin? I mean, by checking the pictures they have much more than eye make up, so I would like to know if all the natural effect is caused only by Your eye-make up, not additional contours based on a custom skin. As mentioned of not having so much difference between them I would like to have only one if possible (I'm reducing my cc to only the best)
Thanks.

The model in the pictures has a custom skintone, & freckles with the light maxis eyeliner.
I think the eyeshadow does give a bit more contour to the lids.
I put a picture of her here without eyeshadow.
I hope this helps.

You're doing a great job with those ^^

Thank you so much for these! I have some Asian sims and it's hard to find eyeshadows that contour correctly with their eyes. Some eyeshadows make them look too caucasian.

Thanks a lot for this, I hope makin asian sims gets a little easier (I've never been able to make a nice asian sim)

Very nice work. Subtle make-up is hard to find, heh.

Thanks for all the positive feedback. I didn't think these would be so popular.

Brilliant! Thanks so much! I might just have to post the sim I wanted to use them on!

Thanks. I've been waiting for your opinion. I'm glad you like it. I'd love to see how you and other people use them.

I love your make up, thanks for sharing

pfish they don't look the same, they really look awesome!
But you could put a little highlights on those, it would look the best ;D

Can you give me persmission to modify that for my next video?
I won't share cuz I never share my work, much less others